Orrstown Financial Services, Inc. Q4 2025 Earnings Call - Record 2025 Net Income, NIM Near Peer Top

Sarah, Conference Operator: Good morning. My name is Sarah, and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Orrstown Financial Services, Inc., fourth quarter 2025 earnings conference call. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After the speaker’s remarks, there will be a question and answer session. If you would like to ask a question during the Q&A session, simply press star followed by the number 1 on your telephone keypad. If you would like to withdraw your question, press star 1 again. I will now turn the call over to Tom Quinn, President and Chief Executive Officer of Orrstown Financial Services, Inc., and Orrstown Bank, who will begin the conference. Mr. Quinn, please go ahead.

Tom Quinn, President and Chief Executive Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Thank you, operator, and good morning. I’d like to thank everyone for participating in Orrstown, fourth quarter 2025 earnings conference call, both by telephone and through the webcast. If you have not read the earnings release we issued yesterday afternoon, you may access it along with the financial tables and schedules by going to our website, www.orrstown.com. Once there, you can click on the Investor Relations link and then the Events and Presentations link. Also, before we start, I would like to mention that today’s presentation may contain forward-looking information. Cautionary statements about the information are included in the earnings release, the investor presentation, and our SEC filings. The earnings release and investor presentations also include non-GAAP financial measures. The appropriate reconciliations to GAAP are included in those documents.

Joining me on the call this morning are Orrstown’s Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Adam Metz, as well as our Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Neil Kalani. Our Chief Revenue Officer, Zachary Khuri, Chief Risk Officer Bob Coradi, and our Chief Credit Officer, David Chajkowski, will also participate in the call. Our financial highlights. Orrstown achieved the highest reported annual net income in the company’s history of 106 years. Net income was $80.9 million, or $4.18 per diluted share. Our return on average equity was 14.76. Return on average assets was 1.49%. Net interest margin came in at 4.04, and fee income of $52.3 million contributed to 21% of the total operating income.

We demonstrated our ability to maintain net interest margin near top of peers, enhanced fee income, and created efficiencies, all while maintaining our focus on leading with risk. Regularly investing in the future remains a key strategy for the bank. We brought in several talented team members in 2026 and will continue to do so. With that has come a strong loan pipeline and enhanced growth opportunities going forward. Overall, it was a highly successful year for Orrstown, particularly with the numerous challenges presented to us along the way. We are proud that we have consistently demonstrated the ability to maintain strong profitability in any environment and expect that to continue going forward. I will now turn the call over to Adam Metz, who will speak about our quarterly results. Adam?

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Thank you, Tom, and good morning, everyone. Our quarterly financial highlights are summarized on slide three of our deck. As was the case with our annual results, our fourth quarter earnings were impressive. Net income was $21.5 million or $1.11 per diluted share. We maintained a strong net interest margin, which, coupled with non-interest income growth, drove our continued earnings and capital generation in the fourth quarter. Non-interest income as a percentage of operating revenue was 22% in the fourth quarter. That’s the third consecutive quarter where this ratio exceeded 20%. As Tom said, enhancing non-interest income and investing in the future remain key strategic priorities for the bank. We recently announced the hiring of Matt Alpert as our Chief Wealth Officer.

Matt’s proven track record in team leadership and his client-first approach align perfectly with our mission to deliver personalized, high-quality financial advice and trust services. Over time, we will look to Matt to bring additional talent to the organization. Our proven philosophy remains that investing in the right people today will lead to continued growth in the future. We are also looking for newer sources of fee income, such as our recently increased presence in the merchant services space. Loan growth was steady during the fourth quarter, coming in at 4%. Loan growth was tempered by some projected closings being pushed into the first quarter of 2026. Growth has been balanced across our footprint and our product set, a nice mix of C&I and CRE, and we have also seen the benefit of our investment in the middle market team.

We remain confident in our pipelines, which remain strong, and the ability of our experienced relationship bankers to continue to responsibly grow the loan portfolio. Credit quality remains strong, highlighted by minimal provision expense, a reduction in classified loans, and a healthy reserve coverage ratio. The bank recorded provision expense of $0.1 million and net charge-offs of $0.5 million during the quarter. Classified loans decreased by $5.7 million from the prior quarter. The allowance for credit losses on loans as a percentage of total loans ended the quarter at 1.19%, compared to 1.21% at the end of the prior quarter. We believe the allowance coverage properly aligns with the makeup of the loan portfolio. While delinquencies have increased, we do not believe it is indicative of a broader trend.

We continue to build capital, which will create flexibility for us in the future. Capital ratios increased across the board quarter to quarter. We remain well capitalized by all measures. Our shareholders remain our top priority. We remain focused on building shareholder value through strong earnings and an attractive dividend. As a result of our strong earnings performance, the board voted to increase our quarterly dividend by $0.03 per share from $0.27 to $0.30 per share. This is the fourth dividend increase in the past 18 months, and our dividend has increased 50% since the merger date. Neil Kalani, our CFO, will now discuss our fourth quarter results in more detail. Neil?

Neil Kalani, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Thank you, Adam. Good morning, everyone. As Adam noted, we finished 25 strong with $21.5 million in net income, or $1.11 in earnings per diluted share. ROA was 1.55 for the quarter, and ROE was 14.7%. Then I’ll start on slide 4 of the earnings deck with my discussion. The net interest margin was 4.00% in the fourth quarter, down from 4.11% in the third quarter. There are a couple of factors that played into this. First, purchase accounting accretion impact to the margin was about six basis points lower in the fourth quarter. Also, the Fed rate cuts in September and October resulted in reduced interest income on our variable rate loans. Continued market pressure has lengthened the lag in deposit rate reductions.

We expect funding costs to come down starting in the first quarter of 2026, and I’m projecting a net interest margin in the range of 3.90%-4% for 2026. As I’ve stated in previous earnings calls, we have anticipated some compression due to the asset-sensitive balance sheet, coupled with a lag in deposit pricing. So the fourth quarter margin compression was expected and will be focused on maintaining it around current levels. If there were no rate cuts in 2026, the margin I do expect would come in a little higher. The margin, excluding purchase accounting impact, was 3.53 in the fourth quarter, as compared to 3.59 in the third quarter, primarily because of the deposit rate lag. Purchase accounting accretion impact, excluding any unanticipated acceleration, should continue to decline modestly going forward.

The core margin, I believe, will increase in the first quarter and stabilize from there. We also maintain our focus on replacing the accretion income from the acquired loan portfolio as it runs off, and we remain on pace to do so. Slide 5 covers fee income, which increased to $14.4 million in the fourth quarter from $13.4 million in the third quarter. Non-interest income for the fourth quarter was more than 22% of total revenues. Wealth management income was $5.7 million, and swap fees were $1.1 million in the quarter. As Adam noted, we’re excited about the opportunities ahead of us in the wealth space and expect to continue to make investments to grow that business.

Service charges are up from the prior quarter as we grow our treasury management business, including merchant services, which has grown substantially since the prior year and represents 17% of treasury management revenue. Mortgage activity has been stable for several quarters, and due to the volatility in some of the components, I’m projecting a quarterly run rate for non-interest income to be in the range of $13 million-$14 million in 2026. Now I’ll cover non-interest expenses on slide 6. Expenses are elevated a little bit this quarter at $37.4 million, up $1.1 million from the third quarter. Salaries and benefits were higher, with increased healthcare costs and additional items that on the professional services line, which were a little elevated that drove the overall non-interest expense number up.

With recently communicated and planned future investments in wealth management and other sales teams, I expect expenses to run at a rate around $37 million on a quarterly rate going forward. However, we do regularly seek opportunities to invest in talent that will drive future growth. Slide 7 covers credit quality. Provision expense was just $75,000 for the quarter. We had approximately $500,000 in net charge-offs, which were mostly offset by the impact of favorable economic factors in the allowance calculation. Our allowance coverage ratio was 1.19% at December 31, 2025, which was a slight decline from September 30, but we believe it is more than adequately aligned with the risk profile of our loan portfolio. Classified loans are down, mainly due to pay downs.

Non-accruals are up from the prior quarter, primarily due to one relationship and not indicative of any broader trends. Non-performing assets remain very low as a percentage of total assets. Our earnings and performance metrics are shown on slide 8. All metrics remain strong. TC is now at 9%, and tangible book value per share continues to build at a rapid pace. Our loan portfolio is discussed on slide 9. Loans grew by 4% in the quarter, with some anticipated closings pushing into January. Loan yields did decline during the quarter due to impact of lower rates on the variable rate loan portfolio. We had $207 million of loan production during the fourth quarter and continue to have a robust pipeline.

We feel good about achieving loan growth of 5% or better in 2026. On slide 10, deposits were relatively flat, declining slightly by $5 million. The loan-to-deposit ratio remains at a comfortable level of 89%. The cost of deposits was 1.98% for the fourth quarter. Due to the deposit pricing lag, I would expect deposit cost reductions to be more clearly reflected in the first quarter of 2026. Lowering overall funding costs is a regular discussion item for management, as well as expanding wallet share and an emphasis on bringing in operating accounts. The investment portfolio is covered on slide 11. We’ve gradually repositioned the portfolio over time, taking opportunities as they present themselves in the market. During the fourth quarter, market dynamics led us to making a bigger shift.

We purchased $125 million of Agency MBS and CMOs and sold about $42 million of securities. This was a strategic decision to help address the asset sensitivity on the balance sheet. The sales did result in a small gain, and the majority of the purchased securities are at a fixed rate, which will benefit us as rates decline. The investment yield, portfolio yield of 4.58% reflects a decrease from the prior quarter of 4.67% due to the impact of declining rates on the floating rate investments. With the still excellent yield and declining unrealized losses, we believe the investment portfolio is positioned well to be a driver of earnings growth, as well as proper balance sheet alignment. Our regulatory capital ratios are covered on slide 12.

After the redemption of subordinated debt on September thirtieth, the total risk-based capital ratio has returned to where it was at June thirtieth. Capital generation is expected to be strong going forward based on projected earnings, and we believe we’re positioned to take advantage of various capital allocation options. Finally, the guidance that was presented in the deck presents a conservative look at what we know we can achieve, and we remain confident that we can meet or exceed current analyst consensus. I’d like to now turn the call back over to Adam Metz for some closing remarks. Adam?

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Thank you, Neil. As Tom said, we are proud that we have consistently demonstrated the ability to maintain strong profitability in any environment. We intentionally guided to assumptions we’re confident we can deliver against. When you put these pieces together: unchanged loan growth, higher fee income, disciplined investment, the earnings profile for 2026 remains intact and, in our view, more reliable. We are optimistic about the future, both in the short and long term. We would now like to open the call to questions. Before we get started, the operator will briefly review the instructions with you.

Sarah, Conference Operator: Thank you. At this time, I would like to remind everyone, in order to ask a question, press star and then the number one on your telephone keypad. We will pause for just a moment to compile the Q&A roster. Your first question comes from Tim Switzer with KBW. Your line is open.

Tim Switzer, Analyst, KBW: Hey, good morning, guys. Thanks for taking the questions.

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Morning, Tim.

Tim Switzer, Analyst, KBW: So you covered this briefly on the call a little bit, but I want to ask about the increase to the guidance on both the non-interest income and expenses. You know, what was the primary driver for both of those? And does it reflect, like, any change in strategy or the business or, you know, anything from relative to last quarter?

Neil Kalani, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: So a couple of things. It doesn’t reflect necessarily a change in strategy. It’s just our continuing strategy of finding talent to drive future earnings. So we’ve talked about in the past that we’ve constantly how we’ve been successful is by investing in talent. So part of starting with the expense side, which has translated to the income side and will translate further, we have taken some actions or we have brought in some talent on the lending side. We announced a new individual, Matt Alpert, on the head of wealth to help drive us forward. There will be some investments in addition to that on the OFA side to help drive that business forward.

So when we see opportunities to help us going forward, we will make those investments in strong talent to drive us forward. So I would say that is modeled in the expense guidance right now. Depending on opportunities with whether it’s team lifts on the lending side or whatever it might be, we could kind of go further in that range. But currently, based on where we stand, we’re on the... I do project being on the lower side of that range, but I do want to allow for some opportunity to invest in talent, as I said, to drive not only net interest income higher on the loan side, but fee income higher.

So the flip side of that discussion is a non-interest income line, where we have had a couple quarters where we’ve consistently been at a higher, higher run rate than we were in the past. It broke $14 million. It was our highest quarter from a non-interest income standpoint that we’ve had historically. I’m not going to sit here and say that that $14.4 million run rate is going to be something going forward because we can’t, as I’ve talked about, swap fees can change from quarter to quarter. It’s a very strong quarter from that standpoint. And there’s the wealth revenue is driven by market, so we can...

I’m comfortable that we can kind of increase that guidance, and that is driven by talent that we have brought on board and talent that we’ve already seen the benefit from, and that we will see the benefit from going forward in the future from bringing in new people.

Tim Switzer, Analyst, KBW: ... Got it. Okay, that was very helpful. And then if you could help clarify a little bit the NIM trajectory over the course of the year. So it sounds like the core NIM should go up in Q1, and you’re already at the top end of your guide going into the year. So I would assume that reflects some moderating Purchase Accounting Accretion over the rest of the year that brings you down, which you mentioned. Are you able to maybe quantify, like, the pace of purchase accounting-

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Yeah.

Tim Switzer, Analyst, KBW: how that should go down over time?

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Yeah. So on a quarterly basis, it’s kind of 2- excluding acceleration, which we can’t- we don’t really predict. It’s generally 2 to 2 or 3 basis points each quarter that it’ll decline. But with the loan production that we’re putting on, that’s essentially replacing the impact, but it’s obviously a little lower rates that will drive the margin down a little lower. But so it’s about 2-3 basis points on that side. But I do. Our projections do assume 75 basis point, 3 25 basis point cuts in 2026. So if that doesn’t materialize, as I indicated in my comments, they’ll- we would expect it to come in higher than that, high end of the range. But again, just trying to account for what we’re anticipating happening in the market.

But there’s potential certainly to do better than that. And we are - we do remain focused on the funding cost side of the equation. But all in all, we feel very good about the margin. We’ll continue to manage it and hope to keep it at or near that 4% level. But there are some factors that can take it lower, potentially.

Tim Switzer, Analyst, KBW: Got you. Okay. Thank you, Matt.

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Yep.

Sarah, Conference Operator: The next question comes from Gregory Zingone with Piper Sandler. Your line is open.

Gregory Zingone, Analyst, Piper Sandler: Good morning, guys. How are you?

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Morning. Good.

Gregory Zingone, Analyst, Piper Sandler: Just pivoting to the wealth management side for a second. Would you be able to tell me what AUM or AUA was at quarter end? And then also, if you have any numbers on how successful you’ve been in bringing some of the Codorus Valley customers on your platform?

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Total AM, total AUM was a little over $3 billion. Did you want to address them? I’m sorry. I’m sorry, Gregory. What was the second half of your question?

Gregory Zingone, Analyst, Piper Sandler: I was just curious if you had any numbers on how successful you’ve been in bringing some of the Codorus Valley customers onto your wealth management platform?

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Yeah, I don’t know that I’m sitting here with an exact statistic, but we’ve seen no significant decline in the portfolio, either from the wealth side or from the depository side, from the commercial side. So as you saw in the fourth quarter of last year, fourth quarter of 2024 and the first quarter of 2025, we did take a proactive approach from a commercial loan portfolio perspective, where we identified certain loans that didn’t necessarily meet our sort of credit box, and we proactively moved them out. And you saw that. But from a client retention standpoint on the wealth side or on the depository side, we’ve seen pretty good stickiness.

Gregory Zingone, Analyst, Piper Sandler: Awesome. And then you guys had mentioned a little bit about the hiring aspect, and you guys are not too scared to hire new people, new teams, and you see fit. Is there an area of the focus for the company this year, whether it is on the lending side, wealth, technology, or other back-of-the-house functions?

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Yeah, I can answer that. I would tell you that in mid-2025, we made a move to build out a middle-market commercial lending platform, and that has already generated significant results in our investment. So we feel very good about that, and we feel like there’s additional opportunity there. On the wealth management side, as I think we’ve shared with several of you, is that we feel like there’s additional opportunity in our growth markets, Maryland, Lancaster, Harrisburg. We feel like we’re just scratching the surface there, and I think Matt and his experience, and certainly around recruitment and team building, will benefit us greatly there. And from a technology side, we’re always looking at that stack.

And I think in this quarter and going forward, we’re making investments to make sure we have the state-of-the-art CRM platform and training the teams to appropriately identify the full breadth and scope of the client relationship so that we make sure that we’re bringing all the products and services to the client.

Gregory Zingone, Analyst, Piper Sandler: Awesome. And just one more from me. Seeing that your capital is building at such a nice pace, I’m curious where M&A ranks as a priority for capital deployment. Thanks.

Adam Metz, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Yeah, appreciate the question. You know, I think we have a very strong organic growth model, and frankly, that’s what we’re focused on. We feel like, as I just shared, we have a lot of opportunities in the business lines, not only that we have today, but enhancing those. And so that’s sort of where we’re focused on. You know, our capital build does present optionality. And so, you know, we’ll certainly – we’ve done 3 in 106 years, and so we’re pretty picky about the partners, and we’ll sort of go from there.

Gregory Zingone, Analyst, Piper Sandler: Thank you.

Sarah, Conference Operator: ... The next question comes from Kyle Gierman with Hovde Group. Your line is open.

Kyle Gierman, Analyst, Hovde Group: Hey, guys. Good morning. I’m on for Dave Bishop.

Neil Kalani, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Morning.

Kyle Gierman, Analyst, Hovde Group: Kind of on that same question, could you provide an update on the company’s current thinking around share buybacks, and kind of what is, like, the near-term outlook for repurchases?

Neil Kalani, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: We’re always looking closely at that opportunity. We’re trying to. Our evaluation, first tangible book is a big factor in that. We’re gonna take steps as needed to where the stock price has been recently hasn’t put us in that position, but it’s, we’re certainly monitoring it, and we’ll. We still have the shares available to purchase. So we continue to be open to kind of all allocation, capital allocation methods based on where our position is.

Kyle Gierman, Analyst, Hovde Group: Great, thank you. And then regarding the recent securities purchases of the CMOs and MBS, could you share, like, the yields achieved on those purchases and maybe the overall goals of the portfolio going forward?

Neil Kalani, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Yeah, the average yield on the purchases were 4.92%. So we have always, and we’ll continue to view that not just as the investment portfolio, not just as a liquidity source and a liquidity management tool. It’s also a strong generator of earnings, and obviously cheap capital utilization as well. So we will continue to be active with the portfolio as kind of the situations arise. We do, just from a guidance perspective, kind of expect the fourth quarter doesn’t fully reflect everything on an average basis. So we do expect some benefit going forward, in addition to what we saw in the fourth quarter from the investment portfolio.

We expect it to kind of sit around the levels where it’s at now.

Kyle Gierman, Analyst, Hovde Group: Awesome. Thank you for taking my questions. I’ll step back.

Neil Kalani, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Yep.

Sarah, Conference Operator: That concludes the Q&A portion of the presentation. Mr. Quinn, I turn the call back over to you for concluding remarks.

Neil Kalani, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.: Thank you, operator. As always, if we can clarify any of the items discussed this morning on this call or on the earnings release, please feel free to give us a call. Wishing you a wonderful day. Thank you very much.

Sarah, Conference Operator: This concludes today’s conference call. Thank you for joining. You may now disconnect.